AIRLINK 60.84 Increased By ▲ 1.14 (1.91%)
BOP 6.32 Increased By ▲ 0.06 (0.96%)
CNERGY 4.32 Increased By ▲ 0.05 (1.17%)
DFML 15.91 Increased By ▲ 0.21 (1.34%)
DGKC 69.12 Decreased By ▼ -0.08 (-0.12%)
FCCL 18.11 Decreased By ▼ -0.24 (-1.31%)
FFBL 26.37 Decreased By ▼ -0.38 (-1.42%)
FFL 9.18 Decreased By ▼ -0.10 (-1.08%)
GGL 10.21 Decreased By ▼ -0.09 (-0.87%)
HBL 117.06 Increased By ▲ 1.16 (1%)
HUBC 114.31 Decreased By ▼ -0.09 (-0.08%)
HUMNL 6.87 Increased By ▲ 0.07 (1.03%)
KEL 4.87 Decreased By ▼ -0.02 (-0.41%)
KOSM 5.36 Increased By ▲ 0.71 (15.27%)
MLCF 38.50 Increased By ▲ 0.11 (0.29%)
OGDC 123.33 Decreased By ▼ -1.97 (-1.57%)
PAEL 21.78 Increased By ▲ 0.22 (1.02%)
PIAA 11.80 Increased By ▲ 0.93 (8.56%)
PIBTL 6.08 Increased By ▲ 0.06 (1%)
PPL 113.07 Decreased By ▼ -1.03 (-0.9%)
PRL 28.22 Increased By ▲ 0.32 (1.15%)
PTC 11.39 Increased By ▲ 0.49 (4.5%)
SEARL 51.91 Increased By ▲ 0.21 (0.41%)
SNGP 67.35 Decreased By ▼ -0.91 (-1.33%)
SSGC 11.29 Decreased By ▼ -0.13 (-1.14%)
TELE 7.78 Decreased By ▼ -0.02 (-0.26%)
TPLP 11.54 Decreased By ▼ -0.06 (-0.52%)
TRG 71.72 Decreased By ▼ -1.15 (-1.58%)
UNITY 23.04 Decreased By ▼ -0.51 (-2.17%)
WTL 1.29 Decreased By ▼ -0.01 (-0.77%)
BR100 6,717 Increased By 68.3 (1.03%)
BR30 22,517 Decreased By -52.7 (-0.23%)
KSE100 65,326 Increased By 747.2 (1.16%)
KSE30 22,146 Increased By 256.6 (1.17%)

The first half of fiscal year 2023 has come to an end, and will be remembered as a time where Pakistan lurched from crisis to crisis.

The cacophony of political noise in an economy teetering on the edge created an atmosphere of extreme FUD (fear, uncertainty and doubt). Inflation ran rampant (CPI averaged 25.0%) and decimated the purchasing power of all but the most privileged elite.

Foreign exchange reserves dropped 24.2% to just USD 11.7 billion as the PKR lost 10.5% against the USD. A hostile external environment where geo political strife led to a massive rally in commodity prices added to the misery of the general populace.

Understandably, the equity market could not remain indifferent to the increasingly shrill narrative that bombarded us 24/7 (thanks to social media) and the KSE-100 Index remained under pressure. Depending on whose estimates you believe, the market now trades at a price to earnings multiple (P/E) of less than 4.0x which is below the trough hit during the global financial crisis of 2008-09.

In such an environment, investors cannot be blamed for making less than optimal decisions which is why they often outsource their decision making to professional fund managers in the hope that they will be able to navigate the treacherous path of investing with considerable more expertise. To that end it would be useful to see how asset managers fared during the last 6 months especially with regards to the performance of their equity mutual funds.

Sample set

For the purposes of this discussion we will limit our analysis to conventional equity mutual funds with a minimum size of PKR 1 billion (as of 30 Nov 2022). This leaves us with 13 funds out of a total of 26.

However these 13 funds account for 94.8% of the total investment under this category so they are an excellent representative sample. For context, the KSE 100 index lost 2.7% during the first half of fiscal year 2023 (July 1 2022 to Dec 30 2022) but remained highly volatile as can be seen from the graph below.

To assess the performance of these equity mutual funds, we will consider not only their return but also the risk taken to generate that return. For that we will use different metrics including standard deviation of daily returns, tracking error and the information ratio to arrive at a more nuanced view of performance during 1HFY23. Before we look at the data we will briefly explain what each of these terms mean.

Standard deviation of returns (SD)

Standard deviation of returns is a measure of volatility or risk. The larger the SD, the larger the variations you can expect to see in returns. SD tells you how spread out the data is as it is a measure of how far each observed value is from the mean or average in the sample. An equity mutual fund with a higher SD or volatility in its returns would be considered more risky.

Tracking error (TE)

Tracking error can be defined as the difference between a fund’s returns and the index it tries to beat (in this case the KSE-100 index). TE shows a fund’s consistency versus an index over a given period of time and is measured by the volatility in the difference between the daily returns of the fund and index. A fund with a higher tracking error is indicative of higher risk in the portfolio vs the index.

Information ratio (IR)

The information ratio seeks to evaluate the performance of a fund by comparing its returns with the index, giving consideration to the volatility of the returns. IR is calculated as the active return (fund return – index return) divided by the tracking error. The IR tells us how much a fund’s return exceeded the return of the index and at what level of consistency. In other words, it indicates how much risk was incurred to generate the stated return. A higher IR will quantitatively tell us that the fund’s return was achieved with more consistency and less risk.

Fund performance

Equity Mutual Fund                 Return     Standard Deviation   Tracking Error   Information Ratio
ABL Stock Fund                     -6 37%           17.12%             5.06%                    -0.73
AKD Opportunity Fund               -5.00%           17.40%             10.35%                   -0.22
Alfalah GHP Stock Fund             -3.15%           13.92%             2.44%                    -0.18
Atlas Stock Market Fund            -5.30%           14.24%             2.71%                    -0.96
Golden Arrow Stock Fund            -5.62%           17.29%             9.64%                    -0.30
HBL Growth Fund (Class A)          -7.31%           23.32%             16.35%                   -0.28
HBL Investment Fund (Class A)      -8.29%           23.79%             16.85%                   -0.33
JS Growth Fund                     -5.18%           11.92%             3.38%                    -0.73
Lakson Equity Fund                 +1.85%           13.14%             2.70%                    +1.69
MCB Pakistan Stock Market Fund     -7.74%           14.52%             4.26%                    -1.18
NBP Stock Fund                     -5.61%           14.94%             3.71%                    -0.78
National Investment Unit Trust     -7 56%           10.79%             5.90%                    -0.82
UBL Stock Advantage Fund           -4 33%           13.98%             3.69%                    -0.44
Average                            -5.35%           15.87%             6.70%                    -0.41
KSE100                             -2.70%           13.31%
Source: Mutual Funds Association of Pakistan, Pakistan Stock Exchange
All data is for 1HFY23 (July 01 2022-Dec 30 2022)

Therefore we are looking for equity mutual funds that outperformed the KSE 100 index, had lower volatility in their returns and did not take excessive or undue risk to generate that performance.

Unfortunately, the data set shows that it was a tough half year for equity fund managers as all but one of the funds underperformed the KSE-100 index during this period. Furthermore, the volatility in their returns was on average higher than that of the index. This is a suboptimal outcome for investors as they earned less than the index while being exposed to more risk.

The table throws up some interesting data; firstly there is a wide variance of 10.14% between the top performing fund (+1.85%) and the worst performing fund (-8.29%). Secondly, funds operated with different levels of risk as is evident from the difference between the most volatile (23.79%) and least volatile (10.62%) fund.

Fund managers adopted contrasting strategies in terms of sector allocation and stock selection as indicated by the wide range in the tracking error (2.44% to 16.85%). In conclusion; navigating the equity market during this period was extremely tricky even for professional fund managers.

Ideally, investors should invest in funds that are able to generate consistent returns with lower levels of volatility. However, they should keep in mind all facets of performance/risk when assessing which mutual fund to invest in and be aware that current/past performance is no guarantee or indication of future performance. For more information on these funds we encourage our readers to research their long-term performance and investment strategy which can be found in the monthly Fund Manager Reports available on the company’s respective websites.

Copyright Business Recorder, 2023


Comments are closed.

Fayez Jan 06, 2023 01:41pm
Mustafa has pretended to write the article from an analytical point while his intentions are clear that he wants highlight his out performance this year (i.e Lakson equity fund). it is important that we look at bigger picture whereby Lakson equity fund has under performed -13.1% in last 5 years while KSE 100 index has returned -0.1%
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Haroon Jan 06, 2023 03:33pm
As the other commenter pointed out, this just seems to be a sponspored article to promote your own fund. Frankly speaking, people should invest money in the stock market on their own. They're likely to do far better with fewer fees (than mutual funds). Instead of writing such a ludicrous article, you should perhaps explain your investment strategy. That would serve as better promotional material than this half-cooked attempt.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Riaz Premjee Jan 07, 2023 12:12pm
Excellent report one of the best that l have ever read on equities ie KSE it is educational for all of us investing in Pakistan.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Riaz Premjee Jan 07, 2023 12:15pm
Excellent report with lots of clarity and an educational piece for even the most seasoned investors his analysis gave me a lot to think in the future as to how to invest your money and what to look into so you dont fall blindly into the Fund's trap
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Yousuf khan Jan 07, 2023 12:30pm
CFA has standards for reporting. Just follow those. 1 year, 3 year 5 year and 10 year benchmarks are the real measure. Anyone can have a bad quarter.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Kashif ALI Jan 08, 2023 02:20am
The article is quite informative by way of introducing TE and IR. However, basis of TE is somewhat not fully understood. All mutual funds love to boast of their performance far better than KSE return. So that means, the Tracking error will be higher, nevertheless and this will reduce IR. So, I would like to understand about it more in detail. And my two cents on investment: It is always better to educate oneself and then venture into Stocks, rather than follow Mutual funds blindly. Basics of both Fundamental Analysis and Technical Analysis can be easily understood. That will help make very well informed decision. Last but not the least, being an individual investor, one cannot take over or cover all ups and downs of a stock market. Liquidity is one of the biggest factor in this regard. So, build a smart portfolio and focus on its growth. NEVER SWIM WITH THE TIDE. Learn to Swim against it.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Imran Iqbal Jan 09, 2023 09:30am
Explained very clearly and concisely.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Imran Iqbal Jan 09, 2023 09:32am
Explained very clearly and concisely.
thumb_up Recommended (0)