KARACHI: Chairman Businessmen Group (BMG) Zubair Motiwala who is also one of the members of K-Electric’s board of directors (BoDs) on Monday called for a thorough audit of the Karachi-based power company’s financial matters, before its ‘distribution exclusivity’ comes to an end, in 2023.
Also, he raised fingers at National Electric Power Regulatory Authority’s (NEPRA’s) performance, saying the regulator’s rules must be redefined and a consumer representative must also be included in NEPRA’s penal for Public Hearings.
Responding to queries raised by reporters at a press conference held at Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), Zubair said that since the federal government holds around 25 percent shares of K-Electric formerly KESC, it should conduct an audit, before the unbundling of the current ‘vertically integrated’ power company.
“The existing audit system of KE should change,” he said, adding KE’s prolonged electricity load shedding is unjust, and the power-hit consumers are right in protesting against the load shedding.
Various decisions taken by NEPRA were purely against the consumers and in recent history, he said, adding that the regulator has never favoured the consumers, as consumers’ point of view was never being taken seriously at the so-called public hearings.
General Secretary BMG AQ Khalil demanded that as KE’s agreement was about to expire in 2023, the government must look into the possibility of ending KE’s monopoly by unbundling the utility service provider and pave way for more players in the power generation and distribution sector.
President KCCI Muhammad Idrees was of the opinion that this huge impact of around 80 percent in the electricity bills was totally unbearable and un-absorbable by any industry; hence, it has to be immediately withdrawn as it was impossible to run any industry at such an inflated cost.
“The industries are already in deep crises because of the devaluing rupee, inflationary trends and eroding buying power of common man whose electricity bills have also been raised higher by at least three times,” he said, adding that neither any industry nor shops or public will be able to bear this burden in the present circumstances.
Zubair Motiwala further noted that the industries of Karachi were paying at least Rs10 more than what was being charged from the industries in Peshawar, which was a sheer discrimination and clearly gives an impression that policies were being devised in such a manner that the industries in Karachi close down on their own and move to somewhere else.
It was a matter of grave concerns that the base tariff has been raised by Rs9.8972 per unit, which has jacked up per unit cost from Rs19 to around Rs30 per unit, indicating an unprecedented hike of 50 percent.
“This is not the end of the story as this increased electricity base tariff of Rs30 per unit will obviously be subjected to 17 percent Sales Tax, Excise Duty and Income Tax as well and when all these components are combined, an unbearable minimum impact in between 65 percent to 80 percent, would appear in the electricity bills,” he noted, adding that if electricity tariffs continue to go up at same pace, the per unit tariff may reach somewhere in between Rs55 to Rs65 in the next couple of months.
He informed that variant tariffs have once again been restored for the industries under the policy of Peak and Off-Peak Hours which was suspended in the past and a uniform tariff was applicable throughout the day so that the industries could carry on their production at full capacity without any interruption.
“The restoration of peak and off-peak hours is going to create a very difficult situation for the industries as they will either have to curtail their production or suspend operations during peak hours and then reengage labour for resumption of pending work during the remaining non-peak hours which happens nowhere around the world but only in Pakistan where such mess usually surfaces due to poor decisions and policymaking by NEPRA which never listens to consumers and only fully facilitates DISCOs.
Expressing deep concerns over restoration and increase in Fixed Charges, Zubair Motiwala stated that this was unacceptable as it would further increase the cost of doing business because fixed charges were applicable as per load on operational and inoperative industries instead of being encouraged to reactivate operations will be compelled to stay closed.
“It is an imprudent move, which is not in favour of businesses or the economy as it would refrain the industrialists from reactivating their closed units. Hence, the government must withdraw Fixed Charges to encourage industrialization and ensure creation of maximum employment opportunities.
Chairman BMG demanded that as the entire country suffers badly due to flash floods and all the cities, villages, highways and markets are completely flooded with rainwater; hence, in this extraordinary situation, the government should come forward and provide relief by pardoning electricity bills for a period of at least two months with a view to support the affectees during the relief and rehabilitation activities which could last during the next two months or may be more.
In this regard, any industrial, commercial or domestic consumer with an electricity bill of less than Rs2 million must be pardoned from payment of bill for two months while the electricity bills of other industries must also be deferred at least for three months so that they could take some sigh of relief and reach a point where they are able to settle their outstanding bills, he said, adding that the deferred bills can be charged later in shape of three equal monthly instalments along with current bill from fourth month onwards which would be widely welcomed as it will minimize the burden on industrialists to some extent.
Zubair Motiwala and President KCCI Muhammad Idrees demanded that keeping in view the gravity of situation and likely repercussions on the already ailing economy, the government must immediately withdraw hike in electricity tariff, Fuel Adjustment Charges (FAC) and reintroduction/ increase in Fixed Charges so that the industries could survive in an extremely competitive environment while the hardships being faced by common man could also be reduced in the ongoing era of inflation.
The ‘unbearable’ upsurge in electricity tariff has created a miserable situation not only for the public but also for the business & industrial community wherein many businesses and industrial units will close down, as it was impossible to absorb such an extraordinary raise in electricity tariffs.
Senior Vice President Abdul Rehman Naqi, Vice President Qazi Zahid Hussain, Former President Younus Muhammad Bashir, prominent members of the Business Community, representatives of Industrial Town Associations and sector-specific trade associations were also present.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2022