AIRLINK 61.79 Increased By ▲ 0.19 (0.31%)
BOP 6.34 Increased By ▲ 0.08 (1.28%)
CNERGY 4.08 Decreased By ▼ -0.05 (-1.21%)
DFML 15.90 Decreased By ▼ -0.30 (-1.85%)
DGKC 68.45 Increased By ▲ 0.80 (1.18%)
FCCL 17.89 Decreased By ▼ -0.02 (-0.11%)
FFBL 25.61 Increased By ▲ 0.01 (0.04%)
FFL 9.15 Decreased By ▼ -0.11 (-1.19%)
GGL 10.00 Decreased By ▼ -0.05 (-0.5%)
HBL 115.02 Increased By ▲ 0.22 (0.19%)
HUBC 112.50 No Change ▼ 0.00 (0%)
HUMNL 6.62 Decreased By ▼ -0.03 (-0.45%)
KEL 4.59 Increased By ▲ 0.13 (2.91%)
KOSM 4.59 Increased By ▲ 0.04 (0.88%)
MLCF 38.15 Increased By ▲ 0.14 (0.37%)
OGDC 122.35 Decreased By ▼ -3.26 (-2.6%)
PAEL 21.98 Decreased By ▼ -0.54 (-2.4%)
PIAA 11.00 Decreased By ▼ -0.08 (-0.72%)
PIBTL 6.51 Increased By ▲ 0.04 (0.62%)
PPL 107.40 Decreased By ▼ -1.00 (-0.92%)
PRL 27.70 Decreased By ▼ -0.35 (-1.25%)
PTC 10.65 Decreased By ▼ -0.15 (-1.39%)
SEARL 52.40 Decreased By ▼ -0.40 (-0.76%)
SNGP 67.10 Increased By ▲ 0.30 (0.45%)
SSGC 11.51 Increased By ▲ 0.10 (0.88%)
TELE 7.20 No Change ▼ 0.00 (0%)
TPLP 11.50 Decreased By ▼ -0.44 (-3.69%)
TRG 76.86 Decreased By ▼ -0.94 (-1.21%)
UNITY 21.35 Decreased By ▼ -0.34 (-1.57%)
WTL 1.28 Decreased By ▼ -0.04 (-3.03%)
BR100 6,488 Decreased By -11.1 (-0.17%)
BR30 22,167 Decreased By -99.1 (-0.44%)
KSE100 63,303 Decreased By -3 (-0%)
KSE30 21,313 Increased By 16.6 (0.08%)

On completion of term of Justice Umar Ata Bandial as 28th Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP), Justice Qazi Faez Isa took oath of office as his successor on September 17, 2023. Justice Bandial during his 20-month tenure was unable to improve the judicial system, as evidenced from the 2022 World Justice Project index, where Pakistan ranked 129th out of 140 countries.

Pakistan’s overall rule of law score remained stagnant at 0.39 in the last five years (2017-2022) starting from the tenure of Mian Saqib Nisar up-till departure of Umar Ata Bandial. No visible improvement is apparent in these indexes in the last four CJPs’ tenures.

During Bandial’s term of office, a heated debate started regarding composition of benches, alleged favoritism, and controversial decisions. The most startling aspect of controversy was alleged preference to some “favourite” junior judges while excluding senior judges from benches hearing important cases of constitutional interpretation.

The former CJP himself adopted two divergent positions when interpreting Article 63(1)(b) of the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan [“the Constitution”].Firstly, when disposing petitions filed for change of loyalties by some members of National Assembly, and secondly, when rejecting the Deputy Speaker of Punjab Assembly’s ruling.

The retired CJP faced criticism even from some fellow judges for taking suo motu notice under Article 184(3) of the Constitution of elections in Punjab on recommendation of two judges. It was done even when the order of Lahore High Court was in field to hold elections within 90 days after premature dissolution of the provincial assembly. He even included those two judges in the bench to hear the case.

The three-member judgement regarding election schedule in Punjab was rejected by the National Assembly through a resolution. It was also noted that in similar circumstances, the apex court did not give any schedule for election of dissolved provincial assembly of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. The natter was rather sent back to Peshawar High Court where petitions were pending.

As Chairman of the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC), Justice Bandial also remained under criticism for appointing junior judges that at one point of time created a deadlock delaying the meeting to fill vacant positions in the Supreme Court.

He also deferred a reference against Justice Sayyed Mazahar Ali Akbar Naqvi. Another controversy related to appointment of the registrar of Supreme Court. Furthermore, a bench headed by him, stayed the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Bill 2023 before its becoming an Act passed by both the houses of Parliament.

He refused to recuse himself from a case alleging conversation of his mother-in-law in an audio. A five-member bench decided this matter vide judgement in open court on September 8, 2023.

The new CJP, in addition to facing the grim challenge of undoing the contentious legacy of some of his predecessors, has to decide many pending constitutional issues, especially defining clear boundaries that demarcate jurisdiction of high courts under Article 199 and Supreme Court under Article 184(3) of the Constitution.

This holds significant importance in order to mitigate the risk of any possible misuse/abuse of Article 184(3), a spectre haunting the country since the days of Chaudhry Iftikhar.

In recent years, according to some critics, there were alleged breaches of Judges’ Code of Conduct that gained momentum during Saqib Nisar’s tenure when he started television appearances, fundraising for Dam Fund, meetings with political party leaders, and even attending their party gatherings. The critics specifically mention removal of senior judge of Islamabad High Court by convening a meeting of the SJC without initiating an inquiry into allegations made by the judge against a high-ranking military official.

The higher judiciary has yet to address the plight of Nasla Tower victims. It is necessary to scrutinize the rationale behind the speedy decision of the 60-year-old land allotment dispute by invoking suo motu jurisdiction under Article 184(3), thus denying right to appeal to victims. The matter could have been referred to high court or other appropriate judicial/administrative forums.

Another critical issue is the judgement in Bahria Town Karachi case approving a settlement of Rs 460 billion and restraining National Accountability Bureau from pursuing its reference. The apex court sanctioned the phased payments. It later assumed political dimensions, after alleged corruption charges against former Prime Minister in the matter.

The alleged authorization of adjustment against fine of remittance of 190 million pounds from the UK government, meant for the government treasury, requires immediate scrutiny by the apex court. Supreme Court sanctioned payment through instalments, but how funds from the UK government could be adjusted against the fine.

As Pakistanis have great expectations from the new CJP, he bears an augmented responsibility to uphold equilibrium and guarantee strict adherence to the principle of separation of powers in the days ahead. On one hand, he has to deliver justice in approximately 57,000 cases awaiting adjudication and on the other to reform the judicial system to consolidate its internal, external, and institutional independence.

This involves rigorous accountability and maintaining transparency in judicial affairs, ensuring that justice is not only served, but is also perceived to be served, as mandated in the Judges’ Code of Conduct.

The new CJP has also to structure/rationalize power of contempt of court, outlined in Article 204 of Constitution. In recent years, this power was allegedly abused, beyond the original intent before the framers of the supreme law of the land.

Instead of using it primarily to compel the executive to enforce judicial orders in letter and spirit, it was wielded against anyone questioning the role of judges, even if it relates to alleged violations of their code of conduct. Even the legal fraternity says that during Saqib Nisar’s tenure, this power was unjustifiably exercised against some politicians.

Article 209 of the Constitution gives extensive powers to CJP as Chairman of SJC, for ensuring accountability within the judiciary. The CJP has the discretion to convene an SJC meeting or shove controversial issues under the carpet, as was done in the past.

If the incumbent CJP collaborates with the legislature to develop comprehensive mechanisms enabling it to amend the Constitution, introduce a robust accountability framework while preserving judicial independence and preventing any misuse of powers, it would be a great service to the nation.

The new CJP faces a host of challenges, including taking cognizance of allegations of corruption within the judiciary, accusations made in some audio and video leaks circulating on social media, and concerns regarding alleged participation of judges in political matters, etc. At a time when people’s trust in the judicial system has eroded and international ranking is among the lowest, the task of judicial reform is undeniably urgent and daunting.

However, this objective can only be achieved through focus on merit-based appointments and establishment of a rigorous accountability framework with adequate checks and balances.

(Huzaima Bukhari & Dr Ikramul Haq, lawyers and partners of Huzaima, Ikram & Ijaz, are Adjunct Faculty at the Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), members of the Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellows of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE). Abdul Rauf Shakoori is a corporate lawyer based in the USA and an expert in ‘White Collar Crimes and Sanctions Compliance’)

Copyright Business Recorder, 2023

Dr Ikramul Haq

The writer is a lawyer and author of many books, and Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of management Sciences (LUMS) as well as member of Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE). He can be reached at [email protected]

Huzaima Bukhari

The writer is a lawyer and author of many books, and Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of management Sciences (LUMS), member of Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE). She can be reached at [email protected]

Abdul Rauf Shakoori

The writer is a US-based corporate lawyer, and specialises in white collar crimes and sanctions compliance. He has written several books on corporate and taxation laws of Pakistan. He can be reached at [email protected]

Comments

Comments are closed.

zaya zaya Sep 22, 2023 06:38am
Qazi Faiz Isa has to look at himself to judge how much damage he has done to the Justice System by his own behaviour and his political involvement and maneuverings, attending the parliament and sitting among the parliamentarians while judiciary is ridiculed. Plus his own dictatorial behaviour in the first under the camera session where he stopped other judges questions from being answered and did not allow the advocates from speaking, overriding with interrupting comment as if a school teacher.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Sajjad Rizvi Sep 22, 2023 07:18am
This article by learned authors highlights the significant challenges facing the new Chief Justice of Pakistan, Justice Qazi Faez Isa. It discusses the need for improving the judicial system's performance, addressing controversies from the previous CJP's tenure, and defining clear boundaries of jurisdiction. The article correctly emphasizes the importance of upholding the principles of justice, accountability, and separation of powers to restore trust in the judicial system and achieve meaningful reform.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
M Saleem Chaudhry Sep 22, 2023 07:45am
A good effort to make an objective evaluation of the ground realities and the challenges the new CJP QFE . However the authors failed to mention that in code of conduct of judges the first thing is and should be their integrity which calls for declaration of their own and family assets with money trail so that they can apply the same to the top brass of the other institutions, Bureaucracy and security forces as well as members of the parliament and assemblies
thumb_up Recommended (0)
KU Sep 22, 2023 11:18am
When parliament holds the sway in legislation, amendment, and even quasi-implementation of laws, it is foolish to expect any solutions to challenges faced by society. One only needs to look at the wrap sheet of cases of our politicians and their daring reluctance or inability to explain wealth beyond means, to understand the futility of our justice system. The less talked about demon that is eating up the society and state is the corrupt practices in judiciary and the British era Criminal and Civil Procedure Acts/code, and its use to persecute anyone at will because the laws allow it, and there are thousands of other sections/acts in our laws that are misused to ensure injustice, with no recourse. It's not a challenge, it’s a designed system that feeds the corrupt.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Tigrs Sep 22, 2023 12:02pm
As long as judges own million dollar homes on govt salary...and cannot provides money trails...they cannot provide justice...they are compromised like generals.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Javed Afridi Sep 22, 2023 12:41pm
Cjp is chief clown of Pakistan
thumb_up Recommended (0)
KU Sep 22, 2023 01:09pm
When parliament holds the sway in legislation, amendment, and even quasi-implementation of laws, it is foolish to expect any solutions to challenges faced by society. One only needs to look at the wrap sheet of cases of our politicians and their daring reluctance or inability to explain wealth beyond means, to understand the futility of our justice system. The less talked about demon that is eating up the society and state is the corrupt practices in judiciary and the British era Criminal and Civil Procedure Acts/code, and its use to persecute anyone at will because the laws allow it, and there are thousands of other sections/acts in our laws that are misused to ensure injustice, with no recourse. It's not a challenge, it’s a designed system that feeds the corrupt.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Johnny Walker Sep 22, 2023 03:00pm
@zaya zaya, Completely agree. This guy was a trouble maker and will remain so.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Ahmad Din Sep 23, 2023 12:08pm
Justice Faiz Esa is upright and honest judge and nation expect good outcome from his tenure. Wishing him best of luck. District Judiciary in Pakistan is better up to some extent but at higher level pendency problem exists and only political cases are heard while general litigants faces problem of delay in adjudication of justice.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
John Sep 23, 2023 02:36pm
People want CJ to stand and defend the constitution and do not let Generals abrogate it!
thumb_up Recommended (0)
AZ Sep 24, 2023 07:33am
@John, Unfortunately all are compromised!
thumb_up Recommended (0)