BAFL 53.19 Increased By ▲ 3.16 (6.32%)
BIPL 22.90 Increased By ▲ 0.49 (2.19%)
BOP 5.67 Increased By ▲ 0.25 (4.61%)
CNERGY 5.12 Increased By ▲ 0.07 (1.39%)
DFML 19.35 Increased By ▲ 0.17 (0.89%)
DGKC 80.54 Increased By ▲ 0.39 (0.49%)
FABL 33.11 Increased By ▲ 0.26 (0.79%)
FCCL 20.25 No Change ▼ 0.00 (0%)
FFL 10.48 Increased By ▲ 0.83 (8.6%)
GGL 13.61 Increased By ▲ 0.01 (0.07%)
HBL 129.52 Increased By ▲ 8.18 (6.74%)
HUBC 123.38 Increased By ▲ 0.88 (0.72%)
HUMNL 8.04 Increased By ▲ 0.04 (0.5%)
KEL 4.43 Increased By ▲ 0.46 (11.59%)
LOTCHEM 28.01 Decreased By ▼ -0.07 (-0.25%)
MLCF 42.71 Increased By ▲ 0.51 (1.21%)
OGDC 125.38 Increased By ▲ 4.05 (3.34%)
PAEL 21.33 Increased By ▲ 1.10 (5.44%)
PIBTL 6.11 Increased By ▲ 0.31 (5.34%)
PIOC 118.47 Increased By ▲ 2.57 (2.22%)
PPL 113.85 Increased By ▲ 3.10 (2.8%)
PRL 31.80 Increased By ▲ 2.22 (7.51%)
SILK 1.10 Increased By ▲ 0.02 (1.85%)
SNGP 69.44 Increased By ▲ 0.41 (0.59%)
SSGC 13.76 Increased By ▲ 0.06 (0.44%)
TELE 9.16 Increased By ▲ 0.41 (4.69%)
TPLP 14.79 Increased By ▲ 0.12 (0.82%)
TRG 92.45 Increased By ▲ 1.15 (1.26%)
UNITY 27.47 Increased By ▲ 0.22 (0.81%)
WTL 1.67 Increased By ▲ 0.04 (2.45%)
BR100 6,815 Increased By 167.1 (2.51%)
BR30 24,245 Increased By 677 (2.87%)
KSE100 66,224 Increased By 1505.6 (2.33%)
KSE30 22,123 Increased By 529.1 (2.45%)

Pakistan is facing the worst-ever economic crisis in its history. Fiscal and current accounts do not balance; and there is no sign that they will in the near future. As reported, the circular debt, which is effectively a ‘subsidy’, is hovering around Rs 4,000 billion. All these indicators are the result of our flawed policies of the past. Whatever is happening is not unexpected, at least, for this writer. It is a logical answer.

Anyone who has some knowledge of Pakistan’s economic setup and the policies that were adopted, at least in the past thirty (30) years in the name of deregulation and undesired incentives for foreign direct investment, would reach the same conclusion. However, the author is firmly convinced that this is not a ‘crisis’ per se. Instead, it is a ‘compulsive correction’ for Pakistan. We, as a state, are not attuned to precautions against illnesses unless we are landed in Intensive Care Units (ICUs).

History reveals that we persist with the same habits even when we return from ICUs with the support of the IMF (International Monetary Fund). We have done this twenty (20) times in the past. This time, however, we have reached the ‘ventilator’ stage and the switch can be set in the off-mode anytime by the Fund. They will not do so; however, for the first time our nerves are shaken in the last thirty years. I, however, see a fine silver lining in this crisis too.

Unlike individuals and businesses, states do not go bankrupt. They default, internationally and domestically, and then in some cases disintegrate if the state is not viable in its existing model. This has happened to the then USSR and Yugoslavia in recent history. Geopolitics and foreign affairs are not this author’s subject, however as a commoner, he see a united Pakistan for the foreseeable future. This state is required, in the present geographical form, by the triangular players i.e. the USA, China and India. This region cannot afford any resettlement and there is no need for it either. Sufficient safeguards are available.

On the economic side, I see a silver lining in the form of ‘Economic Resettlement’. The outline of the same is discussed in this article which will be followed by other articles on specific subjects.

The first crisis which has partly developed and will further aggravate in near future; — formal and informal compulsive restrictions on imports. Notwithstanding its negative effect on the sector, the question from another angle is whether or not it will provide some desired space to the local manufacturing especially in the consumer goods industry. Due to our discriminative policies, favouring trade, our local manufacturing industry, which is the second largest employer after agriculture, has been brought to the morgue. Whether our elite culture likes it or not, in times to come, Pakistan will not be able to finance the imports as it used to do.

We cannot drink imported mineral water anymore. The population of 220 million people with a reasonable sustainable base for basic manufacturing will fill the gap by import substitution. For example, we are used to consuming imported butter; such lavishness would not be possible anymore. The overall consumption of butter will reduce, however, there is a minimum threshold and the gap will be filled by local production for which we have reasonable raw materials and infrastructure. Similar compulsions would surface with many other products including almost all the items of daily consumption starting from pencils to textbooks. We all know the syllabus books of A and O Level used in Pakistan are mostly printed in Singapore.

Another example is edible oil. For example, before the 1980s we were almost self-sufficient in edible oil. Cottonseed, mustard and other edible oils used to cater and satisfy the whole demand of the country. However, once we dropped our guard and opened our country to imports as if we are a developed economy, all flood gates opened. The result is that 95 percent of our edible oil is imported. This luxury has to end as the country cannot afford it anymore. In the 1980s, 1990s and 2000s we used to travel outside Pakistan using our local airlines.

But now thanks to the open air policy of Mian Nawaz Sharif we spend over dollar 1 billion in the form of international fares. We give thousands of reasons for the failure of our local airlines; however in that excitement we forget that even a rich country (Canada), for example, allows only one station for landing in their country. In our country we allow foreign airlines to land in every nook and corner of our country. The present policy may be good from some viewpoint; however, it is not affordable in the present current account scenario of Pakistan.

Another big example is of tiles and ceramics. All of us use imported under-invoiced Chinese and Spanish tiles. Our local marble industry is closed. Now it will compulsively restart. The gist of the argument is that as a result of this compulsive shrinkage of imports there will be twin benefits to the country. Firstly, foreign currency will be saved and secondly, the local manufacturing and agricultural sector that have become uneconomical over a period of time will be revived.

In this regard, it is important to emphasise that, unlike the general perception, the main reason is not the compliance of the WTO (World Trade Organisation). The WTO provides reasonable space for local industry if justified. The question is whether or not Pakistan has the capability to justify its case. This is a matter of intellectual bankruptcy. In our case the problem has arisen due to politically motivated ‘Free Trade Agreements’ (FTAs), especially the one with China.

Unlike the policies of all the governments between 1990 to 2018 Pakistan is required to follow an industrial-cum manufacturing model of economics, not the trade-based one. Now this opportunity is arising not by wish but by compulsion for the people of Pakistan. It is high time to cash in on the opportunity and place further restrictions, within WTO’s prescriptions, on unnecessary imports, and facilitate manufacturing. This will help revive Pakistan’s economy. There is no other option. This process will require a transition in which elite classes will suffer. They will try to create chaos in the meantime. It is about time people overcame that barrier if the country is to be made sustainable.

The second silver lining is re-adjustment/realignment in Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) scenario in Pakistan. We may be among the few countries in the world that has allowed hundred (100) percent FDI even for mineral water and biscuits. The ultimate result is that for over a long period of time the net FDI in Pakistan is less than the dividends we pay on past investments. Now the dollar crisis has emerged which was inevitable. No dividend has reportedly been remitted after March 2022.

It is not expected in the near future. This is not a good sign and the state must comply with its obligations. However, the net result which is going to arise out of this scenario is gradual divestment by foreign entities. Some people may consider it bad. There is also a completely different perspective on this subject. We have yet to see one industry where real technology has been transferred to Pakistan. It is all packaging and consumer goods. In fact, in the automobile sector the deletion percentage has gone down. Pakistan has the capability to run industries which are at present run through foreign investment. We may like the words ‘open world’ and ‘globalisation’ however those luxuries are for the countries which are self-sufficient and have run their countries well in the past. We cannot afford it.

The primary question is whether we want FDI in a pharma company making over-the-counter ‘aspirin’ which can be made by any company in Pakistan especially when even the Multinational enterprises are buying raw materials from India and China. In short, in the years to come 2023 to 2027 I see a huge divestment by foreign enterprises from the consumer goods industry. This will be a blessing in disguise for Pakistan. It will rectify the mistakes we have made in the past thirty years with respect to FDI. Only those enterprises will stay in Pakistan who add value in the real sense. The policy for foreign direct investment is not a rocket science for any developing country. Only those industries are allowed to have foreign direct investment where there is a transfer of technology. In case if there is no transfer of technology then 100 repatriation is not allowed.

As an accountant this writer knows the reason for what we have done with FDI. In the developing economies, FDI is attracted for industrial investment. In Pakistan for the last over 30 years it is desired for balancing our books of our external account. Our Finance Ministers, who were really Finance Managers, wanted dollars, therefore they agreed for anything that is coming in without realising that it has to be repaid without any meaningful value addition in the economy. This simple economics that had been forgotten is now compulsively applicable. Portfolio investment is not an investment in an economic sense. It is currency management. States do not run on principles applicable on individuals.

In short, this readjustment will provide an industrial base to Pakistani entrepreneurs and stop the ultimate drain of corporate dividends out of Pakistan by selling potato chips and soft drinks. There is nothing against real foreign direct investment in this scenario. However, such investment will compulsively be allowed only for those industries which are vital for Pakistan, and not for balancing the external account books.

Most of the industries where divestment is expected are effectively consumer goods industries such as pharmaceuticals, FMCGs like soaps and shampoos, confectionaries, ice cream, automobiles, etc., etc. It is not the intention to suggest any sort of compulsive divestment by the present foreign owners. The only difference which is going to emerge is that on account of stringent dollar availability conditions Pakistan would have to compulsively adopt policies on the principle of doing ‘business in rupees and return on investment in rupees. This can only be done by Pakistani entrepreneurs. We have to create Tatas and Birlas in Pakistan, not foreigners selling fried chicken. Private sector businesses have to flourish with only one condition: earn in rupee and spend in rupee.

The third silver lining emerging from the crisis is with regard to values of real estate. It is observed that a very large size of real estate in the form of plots and houses belongs to by local and foreign investors. In the past, on account of easy availability of dollars in Pakistan and easier ‘hawala’ structure the values were directly or indirectly related to dollars. The prohibition and shortage of dollar will result in a disconnect and there will be a substantial reduction in the real estate values, bringing them closer to correct values.

Pakistan still has the cheapest real estate in the region as compared to Dubai, Delhi and Mumbai. However this crisis will take Pakistan out of that league and the value of real estate will come down to the economic values. This will discourage parking of wealth in the form of open plots, etc., and make the capital available to other local industries. The only check we require is to stop outflow of rupee converted into dollar, for which the State Bank of Pakistan would have to be extra vigilant.

At present, Pakistan’s tax revenue collection is directly related to the value of imports. In the forthcoming future the value of imports is expected to come down substantially due to non-availability of dollar. This will lead to reduction in tax collection. Since Pakistan is in the IMF programme it cannot therefore afford to reduce the overall tax collection. This quagmire is expected to result in real efforts for expansion of the tax base and disguised reality is expected to be exposed. The complacency in the Finance Ministry and Federal Board of Revenue with reference to tax collection is expected to end in order to align with real economics of Pakistan.

Whatever has been said in the aforesaid paragraphs reveals a completely new paradigm for the general economic mindset of Pakistani people. Nevertheless, as a country, we have to realise that in the midst of ‘dollars’ and ‘Dubai’ environment we had forgotten the real strength of Pakistan’s economy and society. We have many inherent strengths and the biggest one is human resource.

Only two examples are enough to demonstrate that fact. First, it is the ‘female-driven clothing’ industry. Pakistan at the moment is one of the best manufacturing jurisdictions and our local brands have shops in major malls in London. If we can do the same in this product line then we can do the same in basic pharma, confectionery, soft drinks, ice cream and pizza as well. Second, we have two IT-listed companies being Systems Limited and TRG where the net asset values are above dollar 1 billion with a very humble start. When they can do that, others can follow in their footsteps.

It is high time to sit down and collect the positive attributes from the present crisis and demonstrate that this country of 220 million people can survive with limited dollars if it learns to live within its own means. This writer’s immediate solution is ‘import substitution’ in every sense as the same can be done immediately whereas it takes time to marginally increase exports. The motto should be ‘earn in rupee and spend in rupee’.

Copyright Business Recorder, 2022


Comments are closed.

Az_Iz Dec 28, 2022 04:45am
Very nice article.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Ahmad Dec 28, 2022 06:01am
Very well written as usual.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
samir sardana Dec 28, 2022 06:22am
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Munzoor Ahmed Dec 28, 2022 07:48am
Excellent presentation for the solution to the present crisis. The implementation will solve the problem. But we are a nation that wants a problem and wants to live in that problem because those who can solve are not suffering and those who are suffering can't wait.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
sajid Dec 28, 2022 08:41am
here we go again... zaidi again with his usual bragging about stuff... yet when given charge of the FBR, he ran away like a coward instead of bringing reforms.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Mumtaz khan Dec 28, 2022 09:26am
Import substitution without any penalty for localization has resulted in the cartel economy of Pakistan benefiting local business elite ….who park the profits offshore ….this policy is a disaster … No emerging tigers of Asia including China have grown without very substantial FDI …which signifies the stability of the prevailing political system in any country …sadly FDI is missing in Pakistan …for which we must acknowledge the reasons
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Asad Khursheed Dec 28, 2022 10:01am
Very nice sir, but please don't pin point real state :) Its simply led to ....... :)
thumb_up Recommended (0)
M. Hassan Dec 28, 2022 12:47pm
The writer has provided very good insight about the Pakistani economy. However, he has distanced himself from geo-politics though it has played a very important role in the creation and existence of Pakistan. I want to comment what he has pointed out that Pakistanis prefer trade over manufacturing. The root cause is Pakistanis don’t identify themselves with this land - subcontinent. They try to find their traces in the Arab / Muslim world. Arabs apparently prefer trade over manufacturing and their society relies heavily on imports. Arabs are our role models. Investment in real estate is Halal while depositing money in Banks on interest that can be used for setting up factories is Haram. There is no silver lining. I disagree.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Ali Dec 28, 2022 12:51pm
Local manufacturing should be regulated properly with healthy (non-corrupt) and functional govt. depts. Corruption by govt depts. and local manufacturers is at that level that consumer in Pakistan is deprived of its fundamental right of getting value for money (also unhealthy and risky products on shelves as very rarely ethics are followed by local industry). MNCs bring healthy competition and quality products above all business and environmental ethics. Import substitution may be a solution but discouraging FDI will only increase cartelization by local industrialists and elites.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Muhammad Haris Zohaib Dec 28, 2022 02:23pm
Spot on! You made it so simple that even a fifth-grader can comprehend.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Muhammad Hanif Dec 28, 2022 03:48pm
Zaidi's Sahb idea of Transfer of technology and promote of local entrepreneurs is best idea to save dollars.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Nasir Mahmood Dec 28, 2022 07:17pm
Nice article with wonderful solution. We need to act on the notion: "اپنا اگاؤ اپنا کھاؤ i.e. Grow your own and eat your own."
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Taimur Khan Dec 28, 2022 07:51pm
We dont need a technocrat government. If it were allowed to make decisio it would be
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Imtiaz Dec 28, 2022 08:47pm
220m, propelling to an eventual peak of 400m people ! It was always beyond recoverable ! We needed to face reality a long time ago, it only gets worst by the day. Stop now, declare bankruptcy, default, start all over again !
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Khalid Riaz Dec 28, 2022 09:31pm
Autarky has is not a good policy for any country to follow. Why earn in rupee and spend in rupee? Import substitution means that we have to raise tariff barriers to protect industries where we do not have a comparative advantage. The problem is that the government fails to tax those who should be paying taxes. So it has to spend beyond its means. Currency depreciates and we land into trouble. How import substitution is going to make up for our lack of political will?
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Syed Adnan Naqvi Dec 29, 2022 04:14am
Agreed with all but I do not understand why there is no mention of cuts in outsized govt expenditures. Reality is that tax shortfalls can be met half way by tax measures and expenditure cuts. It seems to me that the average private sector employee taxes are going to govt and SOE employee's salaries, perks, corruption and pensions with no return of private sector tax payers.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Aamir Ahsan Khan Dec 29, 2022 09:22am
Very well written. If have power will give this country in writer hands for five years, if any one disagree the order will be shoot at sight. Two main issues are missing our judicial system and Defance budget and luxurious we as tax payers given to shameless Government servants.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Nadeem Dec 29, 2022 09:48am
Sorry to say but full of tried, tested and flawed ideas. We need to focus on exports, rather than import substitution. Agreed that incentive structure should be different on the ground of transfer of technology/exports by MNCs. Plus you need to cut down regulations, processes of approvals etc., government expenditures (and size) and put the system in place i.e. make people believe that only they have the power to bring in and take out any Govt from its office. Then Govts will care about the people, not about few who control (and sadly writer is very close to them).
thumb_up Recommended (0)
AZAD LALANI Dec 29, 2022 10:35am
Excellent analysis and actionable knowledge.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Muhammad Kashif Dec 29, 2022 11:48am
We have become extremely dependent on imported goods due to our collective laziness. Now the Pakistanis are paying heavy prices for this because we have been ignoring our economy since many years.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Muhammad Khurram Shabbir Dec 29, 2022 11:54am
Nice article
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Faisal J Dec 29, 2022 03:52pm
Correct assessment and only with sacrifices from ALL sectors we can come out of this crisis and not selected sacrifices that are done until now
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Ali Dec 29, 2022 08:55pm
Excellent article, however the author writes "Unlike the policies of all the governments between 1990 to 2018 Pakistan is required to follow an industrial-cum manufacturing model of economics", as if from 2018 till 2022 the policies were any different. This is either a bias or a technical fact, which needs to be clarified.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Ali Malik Dec 30, 2022 02:25am
I agree with the situation & the suggestions. Implementing in spirit can improve the economic conditions.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Arfan qasim Dec 30, 2022 10:21am
Well said, if we as a nation need to progress ;all our manufacturing, must be to the highest standards available. We must change the mind set, that product s exported should be higher quality, in comparison to domestic markets.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Muhammad Arsalan Mushtaq Dec 30, 2022 10:57am
A very good analysis and optimistic approach towards current economic scenario of Pakistan. We have all it needs to be a sustainable growing economy by utilizing indigenous resources.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Jaffer Feroz Khan Dec 30, 2022 12:22pm
Shabbar sb. is a learned man. I agree with what he has written. If the Govt. gives him authority and power to implement his strategy .... he can stear us out of economic crisis.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Jaffer Feroz Khan Dec 30, 2022 12:33pm
@sajid, regarding majority of the appointments and posts in Pakistan .... an officer is never given the power to exercise his authority. That's the reason Shabbar Zaidi Sb. distanced himself from FBR. In the private sector where Shabbar sb. has the power to exercise his authority ....... he is doing far better than his contemporaries....... A Govt. officer does not even have the power to get vacated an official residence occupied illegally....... what to talk of drawing taxes from big guns .... even the former PM was helpless at the hands of the influential ..... he was finally removed because he wanted to put things right ....
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Dr Muhammad Arshad Dec 31, 2022 10:21am
This article is really Pakistan need - solution based analysis of our present economic conditions. Good suggestions to get out from present economic crisis
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Afaq haider Jan 02, 2023 07:31am
I think import substitution and exports go hand in hand. We cannot loose focus from our current exports like textiles and sports goods.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Haris Fahim Jan 02, 2023 08:46pm
If only you or anyone with your mindset is selected by "neutrals", do we really get these reforms done. Otherwise the political compulsions of fixing some politicians and giving reliefs to others will ultimately put us again on square one.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Muhammad Ali Jan 03, 2023 10:23am
Pakistan is on its knees to due to self destructive policies of post Zia era till now. Giving blind eye to education, research, industry and giving priority to motorways, metros & IPPs were the last nail in our coffin. Pakistan can't escape now from the collapse until takes emergency measures on SOS basis; sadly which is least expected from people who are cause of this evil.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Ahmad Jan 03, 2023 10:53am
I appreciate and agree to "This writer’s immediate solution is ‘import substitution’ & "The motto should be ‘earn in rupee and spend in rupee’.:
thumb_up Recommended (0)
jehanzeb Ahmad Jan 03, 2023 09:10pm
excellent article. Totally agree
thumb_up Recommended (0)
TALHA SHAFI Jan 04, 2023 10:28am
Very well described. I believe we should declare 'default' restart and. That's the only way restrictions could be implemented from scratch. Secondly expenditure cuts on non development budget (in almost all streams) is need of an hour.
thumb_up Recommended (0)

Solution: import substitution

Israel strikes Gaza after failed UN ceasefire bid

$100 billion export vision: Pakistan eyes to reduce trade deficit with China

Nawaz stresses on improving relations with India, other neigbours

Gold price per tola falls Rs3,000 in Pakistan

Sarah Inam murder case: Verdict to be announced on December 14

Iran says reviving nuclear deal 'useless'

OPEC members push against including fossil fuels phase-out in COP28 deal

Turkiye's Erdogan denounces UN 'Israel protection council'

Sydney bakes in hottest day in three years

Debt servicing: CPHGCL urges CPPA-G to make Rs25.4bn payment