BAFL 38.50 Decreased By ▼ -0.11 (-0.28%)
BIPL 17.45 Increased By ▲ 0.66 (3.93%)
BOP 4.06 Increased By ▲ 0.11 (2.78%)
CNERGY 3.08 Decreased By ▼ -0.03 (-0.96%)
DFML 16.50 Increased By ▲ 0.25 (1.54%)
DGKC 43.89 Increased By ▲ 0.14 (0.32%)
FABL 22.27 Increased By ▲ 0.12 (0.54%)
FCCL 11.32 Increased By ▲ 0.37 (3.38%)
FFL 6.38 Increased By ▲ 0.08 (1.27%)
GGL 9.47 Decreased By ▼ -0.11 (-1.15%)
HBL 90.51 Decreased By ▼ -1.99 (-2.15%)
HUBC 87.57 Decreased By ▼ -0.13 (-0.15%)
HUMNL 5.48 Decreased By ▼ -0.02 (-0.36%)
KEL 2.00 Increased By ▲ 0.05 (2.56%)
LOTCHEM 28.51 Increased By ▲ 0.25 (0.88%)
MLCF 30.18 Increased By ▲ 0.72 (2.44%)
OGDC 97.81 Increased By ▲ 1.74 (1.81%)
PAEL 9.99 Decreased By ▼ -0.06 (-0.6%)
PIBTL 3.91 Increased By ▲ 0.01 (0.26%)
PIOC 85.36 Increased By ▲ 0.61 (0.72%)
PPL 74.47 Increased By ▲ 1.57 (2.15%)
PRL 15.29 Decreased By ▼ -0.11 (-0.71%)
SILK 0.96 Increased By ▲ 0.02 (2.13%)
SNGP 46.78 Increased By ▲ 0.35 (0.75%)
SSGC 9.35 Increased By ▲ 0.22 (2.41%)
TELE 6.93 Increased By ▲ 0.01 (0.14%)
TPLP 12.35 Increased By ▲ 0.03 (0.24%)
TRG 90.22 Increased By ▲ 1.18 (1.33%)
UNITY 25.38 Decreased By ▼ -0.11 (-0.43%)
WTL 1.14 Decreased By ▼ -0.02 (-1.72%)
BR100 4,656 Increased By 12.1 (0.26%)
BR30 16,663 Increased By 117.9 (0.71%)
KSE100 46,365 Increased By 87.4 (0.19%)
KSE30 16,172 Increased By 20.7 (0.13%)

The Muslims of the subcontinent of India got an independent state for themselves in 1947. Unfortunately, however, the party leading the demand for Partition of India, the All India Muslim League, never had any concrete and comprehensive economic plan for a separate state. But the Indian National Congress had one in the form of ‘Karachi Plan’.

The leadership in All India Muslim League, including its Quaid, belonged to the legal community but not a single person in the initial team had any sufficient background in economics and finance.

Thus the first finance in-charge or someone with overall responsibility was adopted from the bureaucracy. This umbilical defect has not been corrected in the last seventy five (75) years and even today when the country is in a serious economic impasse the elite as well the masses do not attribute it to lack of economic planning.

Pakistan’s political and economic crises in 2023 are not the result of any particular event of the recent past. It is the accumulated result of the actions taken in the past, especially after 2000. The biggest politico-economic event in the history of Pakistan is the secession of its eastern wing in 1971.

There are hundreds of thousands of pages of books and other publications seeking to explain what actually led to that profoundly grim event in the history of the country; nobody, however, is ready to make a serious intellectual effort to find out whether or not economic injustice was one of the principal reasons behind the secession of the then East Pakistan. In short, they were, rightly or wrongly, not happy with the economic policies framed and pursued by the state dominated by the people from the western wing of the country.

Same is the case again in 2023. There is a serious fear of the unknown but there is no concrete or firm action except more and more blame games. Economics and finance, unlike many other subjects, relate to the future events.

A day that has passed becomes irrelevant. With each new day there is a need for food, medicine, education, housing, security and transport. All these ‘worldly’ things are essential for a human being. Every society is required to provide the basic necessities to its peoples on a daily basis.

The state cannot absolve itself of this obligation on any pretext. This requires economic planning and a determined role of the state. If a state fails in fulfilling its duty it is likely to encounter a situation where the structure, authority (legitimate power), law and political order have fallen apart and must be reconstituted in some form, old or new. It is unfortunate but increasingly clear that the state of Pakistan is gradually failing to meet its obligations.

Many in Pakistan are said to be raising the question that when the state is unable to fulfil its five primary obligations (food, health, shelter, security and transport) then why should its citizens continue to finance the apparatus of the state by paying taxes? This resentment is quite discernable in Pakistan, a country which is not able to generate reasonable taxes by way of direct taxes.

Around seventy percent of taxes are collected by way of indirect taxes, which further aggravates the situation, so to speak. The very high incidence of indirect taxes and woefully low base of direct taxes constitute some empirical evidence of a failing state.

No state can remain isolated from its neighbours for a very long period of time. Furthermore, no state can live on foreign aid and borrowing forever. But Pakistan is one such state that has extremely strained relations with at least one of its major four neighbours, India, and is dependent on foreign lending since its inception.

Moreover, it relations with neighbours Iran and Afghanistan are still far from satisfactory. In other words, we are not comfortable from all three sides of our borders. It is for this reason we have been spending around four percent of our Gross Domestic Product on defence alone. This is not sustainable for an economically feeble country like Pakistan.

Pakistan with a constant high expenditure on defence and a limited tax base has been resorting to domestic and foreign borrowings indiscriminately for the last seventy five years.

Now in 2023 the country has reached a stage where both domestic and foreign debts are no longer serviceable. There may be further borrowing to help avert a sovereign default. However, that action will further aggravate the already precarious situation.

(To be continued tomorrow)

Copyright Business Recorder, 2023


1000 characters
Ali Mar 30, 2023 11:05am
Agreed with the entire concept, and i as a businessman on my small scale is forced to think like as how Shabbar sb has given words to my thoughts and feels. Stay blessed.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Az_Iz Mar 30, 2023 06:26pm
The biggest problem always has been lack of savings and investment. The savings rate has been about 10% lower than other countries at similar levels of development. Food consumption is a fifth higher compared to India. Which means there is less for education and health. Unless all that is going to change, things will not get better. Just seeking loans and support from friendly countries will not go on forever.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Az_Iz Mar 30, 2023 06:33pm
Petrol was being sold at half the price compared to India. Overall cost of living was about 15% less than India. Running a country by providing subsidies, and economic growth based on imports and consumption was not going to last for too long. Loans and support from friendly countries will not be coming to the rescue forever. Country should and can stand on its own feet.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Az_Iz Mar 30, 2023 06:36pm
Exports and remittances have gone up by about $20 billion in the last three years. Yet the country is not able to balance the books. Looking for easy way out with loans and seeking support from friendly countries. A change in mindset can turn things around.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Tulukan Mairandi Mar 30, 2023 09:59pm
Pakistan is bickering with 3 neighbors while the fourth (known as iron brother) is fanning these flames while sucking Pakistan dry, with loans to buy its substandard military products at 7% interest and unabated access to Pakistan resources. The free trade agreement with iron brother is like the final nail, that's decimating industry. Like this, Pakistan can never recover!
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
bonce richard Mar 31, 2023 04:04am
@Az_Iz, India is very smart than us since 1947. Our army making money in the name of Islam and Kashmir. I do not say there is corruption in India but not like in Pakistan.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
mian imran Mar 31, 2023 04:43am
The problem in Pakistan is because we have atum bumb we think we are the bomb jalebi baby. And this makes us arrogant. In 70 years we have not developed any industrys or exports yet we have a big thirst for luxury imports and foods. An example is like every overseas hard working mazdoor who has this relative in pakistan who doesnt work and just waiting for mazdoor brother to send money back to Pakistan so he can live a lazy and easy life. Pakistan is this lazy brother waiting for help from Arab "Brothers". While the credit cycle was cheap for dollars Pakistan was able to use this credit card to over spend and now without any credibility or respect on the international arena we are exposed for the poor, arrogant, lazy and corrupt country it has begun. Will take many years to make progress.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Muhammad Ali Mar 31, 2023 10:11am
The state is on death bed due to inefficient, selfish & corrupt system. We can't get out of vicious cycle of poverty due to said reasons. Out of box solution is the call of the hour.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Awami Apr 01, 2023 07:31am
@Tulukan Mairandi, There should be free trade agreement with Iran and Afghanistan as they are similar, exports are possible. With China not much can be exported at this time , it is one way trade. But it is required as we get important products which are needed in day-to-day life and also in defense area.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Safdar Imam Apr 01, 2023 12:36pm
@Az_Iz, Petrol price in PKR 272 per litre in Islamabad compared to INR 97.2 in New Delhi; not double.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Safdar Imam Apr 01, 2023 12:37pm
@Az_Iz, Not half.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply

We don’t yet know what lies in store for us–I

ECP issues lists of delimited constituencies

Shamshad seeks greater role of provinces towards meeting targets

IRIS system’s capacity enhanced: Up to 0.6m taxpayers to file tax returns on a daily basis

Contracts with IPPs, tariffs and ‘SOFR’: ECC tells PD to analyse impact of change, financial implications

KE tariff hiked up to Rs4.45

NTDC accuses Nepra of unleashing ‘awry’ deductions

Ban on import of smuggled items through ATT imminent

‘Unholy’ pacts with IPPs must be reviewed: Senate panel

APSR for FY23 released: Banks, MFBs process e-banking transactions worth Rs167.4trn

Issuance of right shares: SECP places additional conditions for listed firms