Indian naval presence in Indian Ocean: Speakers warn against dangerous posturing posed to regional peace

ISLAMABAD: Speakers at a seminar on Thursday warned against the dangerous posturing posed to regional peace and security by the growing Indian naval presence in the Indian Ocean.

The seminar on “India’s Maritime Buildup: Implications for the Indian Ocean,” to address crucial geopolitical and security dynamics of the Indian Ocean Region (IOR), was organised by the Arms Control and Disarmament Centre (ACDC) at the Institute of Strategic Studies Islamabad (ISSI) in collaboration with the Indian Ocean Study Centre (IOSC), National Institute of Maritime Affairs (NIMA).

The speakers at the seminar included: Vice Admiral (retired) Ahmed Saeed, President NIMA; Vice Admiral (retired) Khan Hasham Bin Saddique, former Vice Chief of Naval Staff; Brigadier Zahir Kazmi, Director General, Arms Control and Disarmament Affairs (ACDA), SPD; Baber Bilal Haider, Vice President NIMA and Director IOSC, NIMA; and Rear Admiral Syed Faisal Ali Shah (retd), Honorary Research Fellow, NIMA.

Vice Admiral Ahmed Saeed, in his keynote address, highlighted that the Indian Ocean (IOR) was crucial for global maritime trade, with around 80 percent of global oil trade passing through its chokepoints.

Controlling these passages equates to significant geopolitical influence, underscoring the region’s role as a critical axis in global economic and security frameworks, he said.

He added that the shift in the global world order post-Cold War, the strategic use of chokepoint diplomacy, and the potentially destabilising effects of the AUKUS model in the IOR were discussed.

He said that the presence of major powers complicates the geopolitical landscape, making the IOR a focal point for economic advancement, strategic competition, and diplomatic engagements. He stressed that regional cooperation and dialogue are needed to mitigate tensions and promote stability.

DG ISSI Ambassador Sohail Mahmood, in his welcome remarks, stated that the Indian Ocean plays a critical role as a vital maritime corridor, connecting nations across Africa, Asia, and Australia, and highlights its immense geopolitical significance on a global scale. He also elaborated on the Indian Ocean’s role as a crucial arena for diplomatic engagement and regional collaboration. He further pointed out that controlling the Indian Ocean often equates with dominance over Asia, emphasizing its pivotal role in shaping regional dynamics. Ambassador Sohail Mahmood highlighted the active involvement of major powers such as the United States, the UK and China and countries such as Japan and India in the region, underscoring that the IOR is a focal point for economic advancement, geopolitical competition, and strategic manoeuvring.

He also dilated on India’s expanding naval capabilities, the role of Indian maritime buildup in IOR’s militarization, and the impact of these developments on Pakistan’s security and economic interests.

Earlier, in his introductory remarks, Malik Qasim Mustafa pointed out that India wants to ensure dominance of the Indian Ocean with the help of extra-regional powers and strives to play the role of “Net Security Provider”. It militarised the Indian Ocean while rapidly modernizing and building up its blue-water capabilities. It has nuclearized the Indian Ocean. This growing Indian naval presence is endangering the peace and stability of the region. It has heightened Pakistan's threat perception and security concerns, and it could spark a conventional and nuclear arms race in the region.

Vice Admiral (retired) Khan Hasham Bin Saddique elaborated on the great power competition in the IOR. He discussed the strategic significance of the IOR, and the military dimensions shaping the region’s environment. He underscored the non-traditional challenges that accompany this competition, including piracy, terrorism, and human trafficking, which complicate the already tense maritime security landscape. His remarks provided a broad overview of geopolitical tensions and underscored the need for cooperative security frameworks to address these multifaceted challenges.

Brigadier ZahirKazmi shared his insights on the Indian sea-based nuclear capabilities and their impact on deterrence stability. He elaborated on how India was expanding its nuclear weapons capabilities at sea, and how it could undermine regional deterrence and could potentially lead to an arms race, increasing conflict risk.

India’s unconstrained military capabilities, including MIRV, hypersonic, and cruise missiles, pose threats to power. Despite bilateral agreements, tensions persist, and India's inadequate safety system warrants consideration.

Baber Bilal Haider explored India’s maritime ambitions and emphasized on India’s strategic culture, which was influenced by historical and ideological factors and drives its current politics. His analysis extended beyond security concerns to include regional stability and economic cooperation. He stressed that India's economic strategy involves importing, managing choke points, recognizing its economic might, and establishing a strong military base in the IOR.

Rear Admiral (retired) Syed Faisal Ali Shah discussed Pakistan’s ambitions and achievements in enhancing its maritime capabilities and securing its interests amidst regional challenges.

His remarks emphasized the strategic importance of the Gwadar port and its potential to transform regional trade dynamics while also addressing the security threats posed by India’s naval build-up. He stressed according due cognisance to the importance of the maritime domain and shifting the strategic focus accordingly.

Copyright Business Recorder, 2024