AVN 50.85 Increased By ▲ 1.79 (3.65%)
BAFL 28.61 Increased By ▲ 0.06 (0.21%)
BOP 3.60 Decreased By ▼ -0.03 (-0.83%)
CNERGY 3.24 Decreased By ▼ -0.03 (-0.92%)
DFML 10.73 Decreased By ▼ -0.07 (-0.65%)
DGKC 52.59 Increased By ▲ 0.61 (1.17%)
EPCL 44.00 Increased By ▲ 0.40 (0.92%)
FCCL 12.45 Increased By ▲ 0.03 (0.24%)
FFL 6.20 Increased By ▲ 0.04 (0.65%)
FLYNG 5.96 Decreased By ▼ -0.03 (-0.5%)
GGL 10.30 Increased By ▲ 0.04 (0.39%)
HUBC 68.59 Increased By ▲ 0.09 (0.13%)
HUMNL 5.83 Decreased By ▼ -0.01 (-0.17%)
KAPCO 22.58 Decreased By ▼ -0.07 (-0.31%)
KEL 1.85 Increased By ▲ 0.02 (1.09%)
LOTCHEM 29.52 Increased By ▲ 0.62 (2.15%)
MLCF 28.57 Decreased By ▼ -0.13 (-0.45%)
NETSOL 80.87 Increased By ▲ 3.97 (5.16%)
OGDC 79.83 Increased By ▲ 1.43 (1.82%)
PAEL 9.71 Increased By ▲ 0.04 (0.41%)
PIBTL 4.28 Increased By ▲ 0.07 (1.66%)
PPL 61.58 Increased By ▲ 1.09 (1.8%)
PRL 14.45 Decreased By ▼ -0.03 (-0.21%)
SILK 1.11 Increased By ▲ 0.05 (4.72%)
SNGP 42.97 Increased By ▲ 0.47 (1.11%)
TELE 7.25 Increased By ▲ 0.15 (2.11%)
TPLP 13.32 Increased By ▲ 0.55 (4.31%)
TRG 98.93 Increased By ▲ 2.80 (2.91%)
UNITY 15.50 Increased By ▲ 0.27 (1.77%)
WTL 1.19 Increased By ▲ 0.01 (0.85%)
BR100 4,190 Increased By 29.8 (0.72%)
BR30 14,589 Increased By 182.3 (1.27%)
KSE100 41,904 Increased By 217.8 (0.52%)
KSE30 14,804 Increased By 61.5 (0.42%)

Our culture respects the dead. Condolences pour in from near and far, even from ‘enemies’. The faults of the departed are either completely ignored, or mentioned in an elliptical manner to soften the blow. Something like this best describes the reaction to the passing away of military dictator Pervez Musharraf on February 5, 2023, following a prolonged and incurable illness.

The sum of objective, truthful, critical comment and summing up Musharraf’s legacy therefore boils down to attempts to discover some good in what has come down as a disastrous episode in our chequered history.

Musharraf was a brash, undisciplined military officer when young. Twice he came perilously close to serious disciplinary action, including perhaps having to face a military court. He was rescued by his role in the 1965 and 1971 wars with India. From there on, he seems to have lived a charmed life that finally saw him elevated to Chief of Army Staff (COAS) in 1998.

The context of his elevation was the resignation of his predecessor over the suggestion for a formal (political?) role for the military in the national security architecture. That episode involved then Prime Minister (PM) Nawaz Sharif, and no doubt was uppermost in the military’s mind when Sharif tried to dismiss Musharraf in the wake of tensions over the latter’s sabotage of the peace initiative with then Indian PM Atal Behari Vajpayee by launching the secret Kargil operation without Sharif’s knowledge or consent. In reaction and instead, the military overthrew Nawaz Sharif and installed Musharraf in power in the fourth (and hopefully last) military coup in Pakistan’s history.

Ironically, the peace saboteur of Kargil turned into a peace activist when in power, suggesting what appeared to be an eminently sensible path to solving the Gordian knot of the Kashmir issue with India. However, despite Vajpayee’s graciousness in conducting negotiations with Musharraf while overlooking the ‘stab-in-the-back’ of Kargil, his credentials as warmonger-turned-peacemonger failed to cut it with Indian media and public opinion. The peace attempt failed.

Musharraf’s nine years in power (1999-2008) can best be summed up by the major events and turning points of his stint in power. First and foremost, after the ousted Nawaz Sharif was jailed and eventually allowed to go into exile in Saudi Arabia (no doubt due to the latter’s influence), a strange phenomenon overtook Pakistan. ‘Liberals’ not only embraced Musharraf, who mercifully did not impose martial law unlike his three previous military coup makers, they virtually leapt lemming-like over the cliff into the lap of a perceived ‘liberal, secular’ military dictator.

This development was a Godsend for the consolidation of Musharraf’s grip on power. Further, the Supreme Court (SC) not only endorsed the coup (in a long line stretching from Chief Justice Munir’s infamous ‘doctrine of necessity’), it went so far as to empower him to amend the Constitution without even being asked to do so! The judicial guardians of the Constitution once again demonstrated their expedient interpretation of the supreme law of the land in favour of military dictators.

Despite the superior judiciary being once again hand-in-glove with a military usurper of power, it eventually fell foul of him for his sacking first Chief Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry (evoking thereby the Lawyers’ Movement) in 2017 and his subsequent second ‘coup’ of sacking and confining the SC judges and suspending the Constitution. He was belatedly charged (after he was out of power) with treason for this suspension, but never held accountable for the 1999 coup, which the SC had legitimised.

9/11 became both a test and opportunity for Musharraf. Having bowed to US pressure (“You are either with us or against us”), he milked the Americans for aid (mostly military) while continuing to practice a policy of duality: ostensibly supporting the US in its campaign against al Qaeda and the Afghan Taliban while secretly supporting the Afghan Taliban resistance to US occupation. The post facto results are before us in the return to power of the Afghan Taliban and ignominious retreat of the US in 2021.

Long before the developments outlined above on the judicial front, he initiated the policy of enforced disappearances and ‘kill and dump’ to combat the nationalist insurgency in Balochistan that had revived in 2002 after a frustrating hiatus in resolving the province’s grievances of 25 years. His reliance on a military crackdown rather than political negotiations to resolve an essentially long standing political problem led to the assassination of Nawab Akbar Bugti in 2006, after which the Baloch insurgency widened and spread throughout the province.

In 2007, Benazir Bhutto was assassinated. Musharraf got away with murder despite being belatedly accused of the crime. When he was eventually deposed in 2008, he never answered to these charges of the two most heinous prominent assassinations on his watch, nor for the charge of treason for his second ‘coup’ against the judiciary. Naturally, as a COAS, he was protected by his institution to the point where he was eventually allowed to leave the country in 2016 for medical treatment. He was fated never to return.

But then this denouement is consistent with our abject failure to hold accountable all our military coup makers, from Ayub to Musharraf. Pakistan’s history is awash with open and indirect interventions by the military establishment in politics, none of which have yielded good results. It makes sense therefore to include former COAS General Bajwa’s ‘Project Imran’ as the latest unmitigated disaster in this long list.

We hope and pray that the military establishment will learn the right lessons from this long and tragic history of military interventions in politics and leave the political democratic system alone to evolve through the difficult process of continuity, with all its roadblocks, concerns and difficulties.

Copyright Business Recorder, 2023

Rashed Rahman

[email protected] , rashed-rahman.blogspot.com


1000 characters
Hujjathullah M.H.Babu Sahib Feb 07, 2023 10:48am
An excellent write-up but the charge of duality leveled on Musharaf should in all fairness also be applied to the U.S.; we must not forget that Osama bin Laden was a payrolled CIA agent and not an ISI tool
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Truthisbitter813 Feb 07, 2023 01:06pm
An excellent and brave write-up. Bravo!
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
zaheer kazim Feb 07, 2023 01:27pm
what an abashedly deceitful opinion post about a man who was larger than life. Yes, the man had his Achilles heel but corruption was certainly not one of them. His NRO to the two Mafia dynasties was his most incriminating sin and we are paying a price for it. He was definitely not involved in the assassination of BB__ she was given proper security tell the end but as the saying goes when you have an inbuilt propensity to shoot yourself in the foot no one can stop you. It was Zardar who told her to peep out of her armoured car and that proved fatal.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Mian M N Shaite Feb 07, 2023 03:15pm
Be gracious. The man had some good points also. Article smacks of paid journalism.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
TimeToMovveOn Feb 07, 2023 05:41pm
@Hujjathullah M.H.Babu Sahib, "Osama bin Laden was a payrolled CIA agent and not an ISI tool" .. perhaps USA used OBL to bring down the twin towers where over 2500 americans died, so that US could come to Afghanistan where about 10000 americans died so that and bring down OBL where one person died. you guys live in conspiracy theories.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Dr fahad Feb 08, 2023 11:42am
@Hujjathullah M.H.Babu Sahib, in international politics you have to move with your interests . If something is irrelevant that mean it’s irrelevant. These all bin laden , Taliban terrorists are cave man and irrelevant to modern civilisation.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Dr fahad Feb 08, 2023 11:44am
@TimeToMovveOn, conspiracy theories are everywhere . Terrorist should be deal with iron hand
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Usman Feb 08, 2023 01:06pm
What does Musharraf has to do with assassination of benazir and nawab bughti died in a miltary operation in which soldiers also lost their lives.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply
Hujjathullah M.H.Babu Sahib Feb 08, 2023 10:38pm
@Dr fahad, To you the Taliban and OBL may be cavemen but for Western leaders like Reagan and the Bushes at the pinnacle of modern civilization they were the equivalent of the American founding fathers and sub rosa business associates who can be mobilized to check Soviet advance.
thumb_up Recommended (0) reply Reply

The untouchables

Post-budget press conference: Dar looks to pacify concerns

Sindh govt announces up to 35% raise in salaries, 17.5% hike in pension amounts

Met office warns Cyclone Biparjoy now 910km away from Karachi

Fitch does not ‘expect large further devaluation of Pakistani rupee’: report

Hina Rabbani Khar concludes two-day visit to Denmark, Finland

Dubai ranks third among top global cities, ahead of New York, London and Paris

Lahore ATC grants police two-day physical remand of Yasmin Rashid in Askari Tower attack case

Sri Lanka lifts import limits on 286 items as crisis eases

Egypt’s annual headline inflation rate speeds up to 32.7% in May

Zelensky says counteroffensive actions ‘taking place’