BAFL 45.66 Increased By ▲ 0.56 (1.24%)
BIPL 20.08 Decreased By ▼ -0.17 (-0.84%)
BOP 5.34 Decreased By ▼ -0.06 (-1.11%)
CNERGY 4.54 Increased By ▲ 0.01 (0.22%)
DFML 16.01 Increased By ▲ 0.33 (2.1%)
DGKC 78.62 Increased By ▲ 5.74 (7.88%)
FABL 27.80 Increased By ▲ 0.65 (2.39%)
FCCL 18.86 Increased By ▲ 1.21 (6.86%)
FFL 8.96 Decreased By ▼ -0.13 (-1.43%)
GGL 12.85 Increased By ▲ 0.21 (1.66%)
HBL 111.54 Increased By ▲ 0.88 (0.8%)
HUBC 122.23 Increased By ▲ 0.71 (0.58%)
HUMNL 7.69 Increased By ▲ 0.34 (4.63%)
KEL 3.29 Increased By ▲ 0.06 (1.86%)
LOTCHEM 27.80 Increased By ▲ 0.48 (1.76%)
MLCF 42.36 Increased By ▲ 3.03 (7.7%)
OGDC 110.37 Increased By ▲ 2.37 (2.19%)
PAEL 18.97 Increased By ▲ 1.41 (8.03%)
PIBTL 5.46 No Change ▼ 0.00 (0%)
PIOC 114.91 Increased By ▲ 6.91 (6.4%)
PPL 94.72 Increased By ▲ 2.97 (3.24%)
PRL 25.32 Increased By ▲ 0.44 (1.77%)
SILK 1.10 Increased By ▲ 0.02 (1.85%)
SNGP 64.32 Increased By ▲ 1.22 (1.93%)
SSGC 12.26 Increased By ▲ 0.37 (3.11%)
TELE 8.36 Increased By ▲ 0.17 (2.08%)
TPLP 13.35 Increased By ▲ 0.24 (1.83%)
TRG 83.84 Increased By ▲ 2.23 (2.73%)
UNITY 25.89 Increased By ▲ 0.14 (0.54%)
WTL 1.54 Increased By ▲ 0.02 (1.32%)
BR100 6,308 Increased By 126.6 (2.05%)
BR30 21,973 Increased By 434.1 (2.02%)
KSE100 61,691 Increased By 1160 (1.92%)
KSE30 20,555 Increased By 366.1 (1.81%)

Earlier this year, the Securities & Exchange Commission allowed Fauji Foundation’s subsidiaries to inject additional equity of Rs11.7 billion in Fauji Foods Limited (FFL), the dairy and foods arm of Pakistan’s largest business conglomerate. The step will now take group’s equity investment in the dairy business to Rs30 billion, in just seven years since former principals – the Hayat Noon family of Shahpur – sold controlling share in the company - 75 percent - to the Fauji group.

In terms of gross value of sponsor investment, FFL stands at 3.5 times of the market leader, Friesland Campina Engro Pakistan. (FCEPL is the Dutch-controlled giant with the flagship processed UHT dairy brand “Olper’s”). Yet, in terms of turnover, the company is still one-sixth the size of FCEPL. Even so, FFL’s Rs12.4 billion net revenue as of CY22 overstates its market size. Although the company has doubled its rated capacity since acquisition, utilization has remained stagnant at 25 percent.

Industry insiders suggest that the company’s market share is no more than two percent of the total processed dairy market, while Dutch and Swiss giants – Friesland Campina and Nestle – together command 95 percent of the market. With capacity size half that of industry leaders, and three and a half times sponsor investment, it begs the question: why does FFL continue to struggle?

To be fair, the company was struggling even before the buyout in 2015. However, accumulated losses – which stood under half a billion rupees at the time of acquisition – have since risen to Rs 18.5 billion, indicating that the management under new sponsors has burned more equity than the other top five players in the market. Has the traditional management style of Fauji’s failed to succeed in a market dominated by foreign competitors?

It is possible. However, over the years, the sponsors have made efforts to course correct, bringing fresh faces both in the board and management. From five retired military officers on the board of directors – including chairman and chief executive – in 2015, the company has gone to four professional independent directors, and where the only veteran in senior management is the company secretary. External auditors have been upgraded to Big Three, while the workforce has been rationalized from over 1,500 personnel at its peak in CY17, to under 600 employees by end of CY22. Yet, profitability has continued to elude Fauji’s foray into dairy. Why?

Are the industry dynamics uniquely challenging? Of course, the processed dairy industry fell on hard times between CY15 – CY19. An onslaught of negative media campaign regarding UHT safety; use of powdered, skim milk and vegetable based fat; regulatory scrutiny by food safety authorities and the superior courts; along with unfavorable tax regime eroded both profitability and volume for players across the industry. However, profitability returned to the industry in a big way during the pandemic as unprocessed milk became less accessible, and zero-rated tax regime was subsequently restored in CY21. In fact, during CY22 the market leader FCEPL has witnessed growth in bottom line in dollar terms for the first time since CY15, indicating that the industry is finally finding its feet. But not FFL, which saw post-tax losses rise by 73 percent in the outgoing year.

Which brings us to the next question: what has kept the company in the red? Although the management points fingers at higher fixed costs, that alone does not explain the abysmal performance. Consider that the raw material and packaging cost alone eats up 80 percent of company’s topline, in an industry where the average rarely exceeds 70 percent. Significantly, the raw material & packaging cost stood at just 66 percent of topline under the previous management and shot up significantly post-acquisition. Given FFL operates in an industry where raw material prices are highly commoditized, why would the per unit cost of raw/unprocessed milk be significantly higher than competition?

Some strategic errors do come to fore such as unhinged desire for growth and expansion at the expense of profitability. Unlike other smaller dairy players such as Day Fresh and Prema, which maintain profitability by concentrating themselves in regional pockets and investing in niche segments such as pasteurized dairy, FFL convinced itself that it could succeed as a challenger brand. More importantly, instead of growing its share by investing in category development in a market which is still 90 percent informal, it sought to wrestle market share from the established brands through aggressive trade discounts and geographic expansion. The management also insisted on stretching its resources thin by diversifying too quickly into high margin but low volume categories such as cheese, jams, marmalades, chocolate dip, and flavored milk; and refusing to divest loss-making legacy categories such as tea whitener.

Which brings us to the most obvious – yet also most pertinent question: why has the Fauji group not gotten itself out of the jam, but instead insists on putting more money after bad. The group’s investment in the dairy business is made through the DAP and urea manufacturing holding companies, which are themselves publicly listed giants. The sponsor management’s insistence on pouring resources into a business that has failed to turn profit in turn deprives the minority investors out of their share in holding companies’ higher profits. And although the management made an unsuccessful attempt to sell controlling share to a Chinese investor in 2018, fresh sponsor investment of Rs11.7 billion during the current year when the macroeconomic headwinds are only set to take a turn for the worse, indicates that the Foundation has its heart set on staying put.

Is dairy a strategic investment for the Fauji Foundation? It is hard to say. The conglomerate has become country’s largest by concentrating its investment in industries such as power, gas, oil, energy, and fertilizer – segments where it either enjoys captive markets, state subsidies, or guaranteed returns. In fact, the group’s forays into other competitive markets – especially in food – such as Fauji Meat and Fresh n Freeze have also only accumulated losses. Yet, instead of backing off it has continued to integrate upstream, investing directly into leased farming. In fact, its business ventures from fertilizer, farming, to cereals and pastas have truly turned into a farm to fork enterprise, albeit financed by subsidized gas supplied on taxpayer dime.

So, are Fauji’s in it for the long haul? They must be, especially if you buy the theory that sponsors want to stick around in case Pakistan’s hostile macroeconomic environment drives foreign players out of the market. That’s a big bet to place, but then Fauji’s may be the only ones with the wherewithal and influence to make one. Does it says something about betting on the wrong horse? Only time can tell.


Comments are closed.

Haroon Mar 16, 2023 12:28pm
Hayat Noons swindled the Faujis. As simple as that. The 2015 buyout was shocking. Fauji have also failed to realize that the only way to compete with Nestle or Olpers is to really undercut on price, and they have undercut them on price but not my much.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Abdullah Mar 16, 2023 03:04pm
Unprofessional behavior. Strange aggressive marketing strategies. No proper hiring of internal and compliance professional . A fauji general terminated head of audit as the auditee was not happy. They do not have independent board or BAC. It was doomed to fail. I am not shocked even 0.1% knowing these facts. Mindset of faujis needs to change that makes them to think that they can performs in politics , corporate ,journalism and in fact in every field !
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Adnan Aziz Mar 16, 2023 03:44pm
FAUJI FOUNDATION has been declared free from any Taxes. Why? Why? Why? I shall not be convinced with any explanation. I shall not be.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Adnan Aziz Mar 16, 2023 03:45pm
@Abdullah , I agree with you, especially the last para of your comments and can say much more but.....
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Tulukan Mairandi Mar 16, 2023 04:20pm
Great. Army State.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Leo Mar 16, 2023 08:02pm
They are best in one thing only BUSINESS
thumb_up Recommended (0)
KhanRA Mar 16, 2023 09:21pm
This favouritism for the establishment fauji is bad for Pakistani business because they get unfair advantages. They don’t pay taxes. They will destroy the private sector. Why do we even have a country? Let us just give everything to Fauji.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
KhanRA Mar 16, 2023 11:41pm
@Haroon, Fauji shouldn’t be in the business of competing with private industry in any field. Job of fauji is to protect the borders of this country. Nothing else.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Umair Usman Mar 17, 2023 09:15am
@Adnan Aziz, all foundations are TAx free bhai sahib
thumb_up Recommended (0)
amjad Mar 17, 2023 09:40am
FFC contributed Rs 30 billion in taxes and levies during the year and also enabled saving of precious foreign exchange of over USD 1.65 billion via import substitution for the Country. FFC was presented with the Largest National Taxpayer Award for Manufacturing sector by the Rawalpindi Chamber of Commerce & Industry (RCCI).
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Talha Mar 17, 2023 11:28pm
@Adnan Aziz, I would be really interested in knowing what they have to say.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Talha Mar 17, 2023 11:31pm
@Umair Usman, sorry but you get that fauji foundation is not non profit organization. I am really convinced with your knowledge brother.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Saleem Mar 18, 2023 03:47pm
Govt should be asked to put surcharge on electricity to be paid to Fauji Foods to bring it out of financial troubles!!! Issue resolved.
thumb_up Recommended (0)
Abdullah Mar 18, 2023 06:09pm
Unfortunately arrogance and big ego will always prevent one from learning from his mistakes, you need some degree of humility to reflect and ask what went wrong.
thumb_up Recommended (0)