Guardian misreported on alleged return of P2 virus: Health minister

Babar bin Atta says not even once was he approached by Guardian for this matter. "Guardian has confused P2 wit
08 Nov, 2019
  • Babar bin Atta says not even once was he approached by Guardian for this matter.
  • "Guardian has confused P2 with Vaccine Derived Polio Virus or Sabin-Like Type 2 Derived," Atta said. 

The State Minister of Health Zafar Mirza has refuted The Guardian’s report that P2 poliovirus has returned to Pakistan and was concealed by former Prime Minister's Focal Person for Polio Eradication Babar bin Atta.

On Thursday, The Guardian reported that officials in Pakistan had hidden the outbreak of several cases of P2 strain of polio, which causes paralysis and primarily effects those under five. However, Mirza dismissed of the coverup of the polio cases as claimed by the international media.

"Sabin-like type 2 derived virus outbreak in Pakistan is vigilantly being monitored and appropriately responded. Such outbreaks are being reported from countries even after Polio eradication e.g. Nigeria, China, Indonesia, Congo," Mirza tweeted.

Similarly, Atta has also denied the report saying that the international media had confused P2 with Vaccine Derived Polio Virus (cVPDVs) or Sabin-Like Type 2 Derived (SLT2D).  The former focal person further said that the reporter of the article was based in New Delhi and had not even approached him once for information.

"Guardian never approached me for any comment or else I would have educated them on the difference between cVPDVs and P2. They have completely mixed the two making a perfect case of Defamation," he wrote on Twitter. Atta added that The Guardian now needs to prove that P2 poliovirus has returned to Pakistan.

Atta further said that the SLT2D has caused seven cases of paralysis in recent months, mainly in the northern parts of Pakistan. "The only way to reduce the risks of further transmission is to address gaps in immunization coverage.  The programme is working on a comprehensive outbreak response that includes rounds of vaccination in the area to protect every child under the age of five years," an official statement from the polio program stated.

Read Comments