Bush replaces advisers on cloning, medical issues

29 Feb, 2004

US President George W. Bush reshuffled his advisory council on cloning and related medical issues on Friday, adding a prominent neurosurgeon known for his work on conjoined twins and two conservatives who have spoken out strongly against cloning.
He replaced one of the most prominent scientists on his Council on Bioethics, cell biology expert Elizabeth Blackburn of the University of California San Francisco.
The Australian- born Blackburn has spoken in favour of so-called therapeutic cloning in which cloning technology is used for medical and biological research.
He also replaced William May, a prominent Christian bioethicist and a former president of the American Academy of Religion, now at the University of Virginia.
The new members of the panel are Dr Benjamin Carson of Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, a paediatric neurologist; Peter Lawler, a government professor at Berry College in George; and Diana Schaub, a political scientist at Loyola College of Maryland.A White House spokeswoman said Blackburn's and May's terms had expired.
"We decided to appoint other individuals at this point with different experience and expertise," she said.
But supporters of therapeutic cloning said they were stunned by the move and said it showed the White House was not interested in hearing neutral scientific advice.
"The American people deserve the right science, not right-wing ideology, on critical issues facing their health," Massachusetts Sen. Edward Kennedy, a Democrat, said in a statement.
"By firing two of the committee's most distinguished members, the administration is choosing once again the most divisive and ideological course, instead of seeking consensus".

Read Comments