The 1965 War - A saga of Indian defeat
(An analysis of Indian historians and others): "In the Jammu - Sialkot Sector, the Indian Army massed the largest chunk of its might ie 1 Corps consisting of one Armoured Division (one Armoured Brigade and one Lorried Brigade), two Infantry Divisions and one Mountain Division. However, 1 Corps did not achieve proportionate results. Here again, bad generalship at the Corps and the Divisional levels, and lack of co-operation among the formations, were responsible for their poor showing.".
Copyright Business Recorder, 2014
Above quotes are from chapter 12 of the Indian Official History of 1965 war. The Indian official History is full of such observations about the inefficiency of their military leadership during 1965 which ultimately led them to defeat.
On the morning of 6th September when Indian crossed into Pakistan territory in the Burki Sector, the higher ups had assured their under command that they would have their breakfast in Lahore. But in the next few days the Indian Army was to learn that a nation's spirit could never be taken lightly.
An American Radio Service Journalist Rai Milan writes in his war diary "I want to bring it on record that India is claiming victory but on ground there is no evidence to support Indian claims. What I see is only destroyed Indian tanks and huge logistic support units rolling towards their forward area. During my long journalistic career spanning over two decades, I have never seen a group of such confident individuals as the victorious Pakistani soldiers fighting against Indians".
In the Wikipedia (The Free Encyclopedia), while analysing the war of 1965 it is written that invasion of Pakistan by the Indian Army was a strategic blunder. Indian Army failed to analyse the real potential of Pakistan Army which resultanted into their defeat. The official History of the 1965 War drafted by the Indian Ministry in 1992 was a long suppressed document that outlined intelligence and strategic blunders by India during war. According to the document, on September 22, when the Security Council was pressing for a cease-fire, the Indian Prime Minister asked the General Chaudhri if India could possibly win the war, were he delay accepting the cease-fire for a little while longer. The General replied that most of the India's frontline ammunition had been used up and the Indian Army had suffered tank losses.
It was revealed later that only 14% of India's frontline ammunition had been fired and India still held twice the number of tanks than Pakistan. By this time the Pakistan Army had used up about to 80% of its ammunition. Air Chief Marshal (Retired) P.C. Lal, who was the Vice Chief of Air Staff during the conflict, points to the lack of co-ordination between the IAF and the Indian Army. Neither side revealed its battle plans to the other. The battle plans drafted by Ministry of Defence and General Chaudhri, did not specify a role for the Indian Air Force in the order of battle.
There are hundreds of other blunders by the Indian Intelligence and their field commanders. Pakistan Army, with backing of the entire nation, stood like a cemented wall against Indian onslaught on all fronts. On the Sialkot front one Indian Infantry, one Armoured Division and an Armoured Brigade were repulsed by an Infantry Division.Fifteen Indian attacks were repulsed only at Chawida - Philora Sectors. Indian had to face the biggest of humiliations on the Lahore front, where thirteen of their attacks were repulsed. At Kasur Pakistani forces not only repulsed many Indian attacks but went deep into India and captured a substantial chunk of their territory. The spirited Pakistani nation faced boldly the Indian might and defeated them on all fronts. There have been rare examples of extreme valour and courage in military history as were witnessed during 1965 both by Pakistani nation and soldiers. Despite numerical superiority Indians were humiliated on all fronts in sea, air and ground. The war that India foisted on Pakistan on September 6, 1965 was the product of several years of constant and deliberate planning in New Delhi. The underlying Indian philosophy behind this aggressive attack on a smaller neighbour Pakistan was to take revenge of the division of India in 1947 and endeavour to reverse the freedom and independence of the Muslims of Pakistan. The war that continued with full resolve and determination in the ranks and file of Pakistani armed forces proved once and for ever, that the valiant Pakistani soldiers backed by a resolute nation were not to be cowed by Indian threats and intimidations.
The changing global environment and challenges faced by us today demand same unity, faith, discipline and determination which the nation displayed forty one year ago during 1965 war. After the October 8th earthquake, last year, the nation once again proved that whether it is a natural calamity or a foreign aggression, the Pakistani nation is ready to face all challenges with fortitude and courage. It was heartening to see when every individual of this nation came out to help their brethren in distress and pain in Azad Kashmir and NWFP who were affected due to earthquake.